Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary to Middletown, NY buses and trains from $36

Here are some trips other travelers have found on Routefriend.
$36
5h 52m
1 stop
GotoBus NJTransit
$68
5h 24m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$77
7h 40m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$102
7h 49m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit