Indianapolis, IN to New York, NY buses and trains from $75

Or, see buses and trains from New York, NY to Indianapolis, IN.
Here are some trips other travelers have found on Routefriend.
$75
18h 10m
0 stops
Greyhound
$90
21h 57m
0 stops
Amtrak
$114
1d 9h
2 stops
Megabus Greyhound