Newark, NJ to Middletown, NY buses and trains from $32

Or, see buses and trains from Middletown, NY to Newark, NJ.
Here are some trips other travelers have found on Routefriend.
$32
7h 22m
3 stops
BoltBus NJTransit
$34
2h 27m
2 stops
CoachUSA NJTransit
$40
2h 36m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$45
3h 48m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$47
2h 15m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$47
3h 48m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$50
3h 49m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$52
2h 27m
2 stops
Amtrak NJTransit
$58
5h 7m
3 stops
Amtrak NJTransit